Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Tall closed windows light an aged walnut window seat with an oatmeal wool cushion and layered linen and umber curtains; a redwood trunk and sword ferns are visible outside.

In Mill Valley, the Size of the ADU Now Decides How Much the House Can Grow

October 8, 2026

"Every square foot in Mill Valley is over $1,000," Danielle Staude, the city's planning and building director, told the City Council in September. At that price, a buyer pays close attention to how much more house a lot is allowed to hold. In Mill Valley, an existing accessory dwelling unit has been quietly using up that allowance.

That changes this month. On September 21, 2026, the Mill Valley City Council voted 5–0 to adopt an amendment to Mill Valley Municipal Code Section 20.16.040(A)(1)(b). The amendment subtracts up to 800 square feet of legal ADU area from the city's adjusted floor area calculation. The rules take effect 30 days after adoption, which puts the date at October 21, 2026, and from then on they apply to planning applications. For anyone pricing or buying a single-family home with a second unit, the exemption has a hard edge. An ADU of 800 square feet or less drops out of the calculation completely. An ADU even slightly bigger gets no exemption at all.

How an ADU Used Up a House's Room to Grow

The problem started with how state law and local code fit together. Since 2021, Mill Valley's staff report says California has let property owners go over local maximum floor area limits to build an ADU of up to 800 square feet. It explains that local jurisdictions only have to allow that overage when they approve the ADU. Once the unit is built, it can be counted toward local floor area standards. Mill Valley took that approach, and the report notes that Novato and Corte Madera read the law the same way.

In practice, many owners only found out later. Staff wrote that "property owners with existing legal ADUs commonly learn that the ADU floor area now counts toward the adjusted floor area, reducing the potential for future home additions." Mill Valley used to have its own floor area bonus for ADUs, and owners who built under that bonus were surprised to learn their square footage now counted.

ADUs above detached garages fared worst. Staff described them as "common throughout Mill Valley." They don't qualify for the state's 800-square-foot exemption, but the old local bonus did cover them. Under the rules in place until this month, a home with an older unit over the garage could have less room left to expand than the same home with no second unit.

How Mill Valley Measures a House

To see what the amendment is worth, you need the base formula. The Mill Valley Municipal Code's adjusted floor area starts with gross floor area, measured from the outside faces of structural walls. It adds up every enclosed structure on the lot: the main house, accessory structures, second units and ADUs, and permitted sheds. Enclosed patios, terraces and balconies count too.

A few provisions catch buyers off guard:

  • Enclosed undeveloped space counts if it has an area of at least 8 by 10 feet with 7 feet of headroom, without any excavation.
  • Basements are excluded, along with spaces open on at least two sides and structures such as carports and gazebos.
  • Interior space taller than 14 feet counts at a 50% premium, so a double-height living room uses up more of the allowance than its footprint suggests.
  • Effective lot area leaves out recorded trail, driveway, landscaping, parking and roadway easements, so the lot area on a listing sheet may not be the number the city uses.

The maximum is then set by effective lot area.

Effective lot area

Maximum adjusted floor area

Under 8,000 sq ft

35% of lot area

8,000 to 20,000 sq ft

2,000 sq ft plus 10% of lot area

Over 20,000 sq ft

3,000 sq ft plus 5% of lot area, capped at 7,000 sq ft

On the city's worksheet, a 4,000-square-foot lot gets a maximum of 1,400 square feet, and an 80,000-square-foot lot hits the 7,000-square-foot cap. Design review can lower the maximum further. From the total, the code already subtracts up to 500 square feet of garage area. That subtraction stays, and the legal ADU exemption is added on top of it.

The 800-Square-Foot Cutoff

The adopted text subtracts "up to a total of 800 square feet of floor area for legal Accessory Dwelling Unit(s) that do not exceed 800 square feet in size and excluding all Junior ADUs." Staude explained what that wording means at the September 8 meeting: "If you propose a 1,000-square-foot ADU, you will not be granted 800 square feet of that 1,000-square-foot ADU." So a 1,000-square-foot unit doesn't get a partial credit. It gets none.

Here is a hypothetical example using the code's own formula. Assume a 10,000-square-foot effective lot, which gives a maximum adjusted floor area of 3,000 square feet. The lot has a 2,300-square-foot house and a 450-square-foot detached garage.

  1. With a 600-square-foot legal ADU over the garage, under the old rule: 2,300 plus 450 plus 600 is 3,350. Subtract the 450-square-foot garage and you get 2,900. That leaves about 100 square feet for an addition.
  2. The same property after October 21: the 600-square-foot ADU is also subtracted, which brings the total to 2,300. That leaves about 700 square feet for an addition.
  3. With an 850-square-foot ADU instead: no ADU exemption applies. The total is 3,150 after the garage subtraction, which is already over the 3,000-square-foot maximum, so the main house has no room to grow.

On the same lot with the same house, a 250-square-foot difference in ADU size decides whether you can add a bedroom wing or nothing at all. Real results depend on the city's review, including the 14-foot height premium and any recorded easements, but the math shows why "has an ADU" tells a buyer very little. The unit's exact square footage and whether it is legal now carry real weight in the price.

Why the City Drew the Line at 800

The cutoff follows state law and reflects what the council wants built. Staff recommended limiting the exemption to the first 800 square feet "to align with state law, while also continuing to encourage modestly scaled ADUs that are compatible with surrounding neighborhoods." Junior ADUs were left out because they don't get the same state incentives and, in staff's words, "are not utilized as intended (as secondary living units)."

The council has preferred small units before. Councilmember Urban Carmel noted that Mill Valley capped ADUs at 500 square feet a decade ago to encourage affordable construction and rentals. After the September meeting, he told the Marin Independent Journal that smaller ADUs suit the denser neighborhoods, where larger structures can look outsized. Staude framed the goal as rentals. She said that ADUs, "if they're not rented out," don't actually help with affordability.

That points to the city's other lever. Under its Lease to Locals program, an owner who turns a home, an ADU or a room into a long-term rental of at least 12 months can receive up to $14,000. In August 2026 the city extended the program through June 2027. As of that announcement, more than 40 owners had expressed interest and two properties had converted. The Lease to Locals program guidelines, last updated February 27, 2026, cap rent for a private unit at $4,500 a month. A qualified tenant is an adult who works at least 20 hours a week for clients based in, or an employer located in, ZIP code 94941. Grants are paid in two halves, one when the lease is signed and the other after the lease term is completed.

The two policies push the same way. The floor area exemption makes a small legal ADU cost the main house nothing in future expansion, and Lease to Locals pays the owner to rent it to someone who works locally. A buyer looking at a property with a compliant unit under 800 square feet now has both options open.

What to Verify Before You Write an Offer

The exemption applies only to legal ADUs, so the paperwork matters as much as the floor plan. On any Mill Valley home with a second unit, ask for:

  • Permit history for the ADU. An unpermitted unit doesn't qualify for the subtraction as written.
  • The unit's measured square footage, taken from the exterior faces of structural walls the way the code measures it, rather than the marketing figure.
  • Whether the unit is a Junior ADU. JADUs are excluded from the exemption no matter their size.
  • Recorded easements on the title report, since they reduce effective lot area and with it the maximum.
  • Any interior space taller than 14 feet in the main house, which counts at a premium.
  • Enclosed crawl or attic space with 7 feet of headroom, which can count even though it isn't finished.

The city's adjusted floor area worksheet lays out the calculation in the same order planners use. Running it yourself, then confirming with the Planning and Building Department, takes far less time than finding out after closing that an addition you planned isn't allowed.

FAQ

Is the change in effect today? ⌄

Not yet. The council adopted it on September 21, 2026, and the regulations take effect 30 days later, on October 21, 2026. At the time of writing, no ordinance number had been published.

Could the ADU rules change again soon? ⌄
Possibly. The council's August 31 work plan says staff is preparing a broader update to the ADU regulations for Planning Commission and Council review this fall, timed to the state legislative season. Staff has also said more code refinements may be recommended as part of that update. No hearing date for it had been posted as of this writing.
Does the garage exemption still apply if the ADU sits above the garage? ⌄
Yes. The adopted text lists the 500-square-foot garage subtraction and the 800-square-foot ADU subtraction as separate items, and both can apply to the same property. Councilmember Katherine Jones confirmed with staff that this could add up to 1,300 square feet exempted on any lot.

This post is general information, not legal advice. Confirm any floor area calculation with the City of Mill Valley Planning and Building Department.

If you own a Mill Valley home with a second unit, its size and permit history now affect how buyers will value the property. Sarkissian Bullock Team can review your ADU against the new floor area math and show you how to present that headroom in your pricing and marketing. Request a Confidential Valuation.

Work With

The Sarkissian Bullock Team is consistently regarded as the best and most trustworthy realty service found anywhere, offering their keen, personal advice to their clients.